Comparative Studies of Quran

Comparative Studies of Quran

A comparative study on the method of the commentators of the Tanzili interpretations of "Hamgam Ba Vahye: Abdolkarim Bahjatpor" & "Ma'arij al-Tafkar va Daqayeq -Atafakor: Abdorahman Hasan Habanoke Almeydani "

Document Type : Original

Authors
Mostafa Attar Abkenari 1
Fateme Darabi 2
Eslam Zohrabi Asl 3
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Studies, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
2 Ph.D. student of Theology and Islamic Studies, Islamic Azad University, South Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran. h
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Maaref Islami, Islamic Azad University Karaj Branch
Abstract
Tanzili interpretation means interpretation in the order of revelation of the surah, an emerging style in the interpretation of the Qur'an that its commentators try to achieve a deeper understanding of the verses of the Holy Qur'an by using the order of revelation of the suras. Including commentators who have interpreted in this way; Abdul Rahman Hassan Habbankeh Al-Maidani and Abdul Karim Behjatpour, who, despite many differences in theological views and interpretive methods, have based their movement on interpretation, the revelation of the Qur'an and considered it the best way to achieve the knowledge of the Qur'an.
This descriptive-analytical study, by comprehensively examining these two interpretations, seeks to compare and apply the interpretive method of these two commentators and express their commonalities and differences in Tanzili interpretation, and it has been concluded that the main common point of these interpretations is more than in appearance, in terms of their writing in descending order, and in terms of content, opinions and how the interpreter interacts with the verses, they have many points of difference. This is well illustrated by the way the verses are referred to for commentary and elaboration in these commentaries.

This descriptive-analytical study, by comprehensively examining these two interpretations, seeks to compare and apply the interpretive method of these two commentators and express their commonalities and differences in discount interpretation, and has concluded that the main common point of these interpretations is more than In terms of appearance, that is, their writing is in descending order, and in terms of content, opinions and how the interpreter interacts with the verses, they have many points of difference. This is well illustrated by the way the verses are referred to for commentary and elaboration in these commentaries.
Keywords
Tanzili Tafsir
Hamgam Ba Vahye
Behjatpour
Maarej Al-Tafkar
Al-Maidani

Subjects

  1. The Noble Qur’an

    1. Eskandarlo, Mohamad Javad (1385): "Mostashreghan & Dating of Qur’an", Qum: Pajohesh Haye Tafsir Va Olom Qur’an Publication.
    2. Bazargan, Mahdi (1385): "The Evolution of the Qur’an", Tehran: Serkat Sahami Enteshar Publication.
    3. Bahjat Por, Abdol karim (1393): "Hamgam ba Vahye" Qum: The Institute of Tamhid’s Publication.
    4. Bahjat Por, Abdol karim (1395): "Tafsir Tanzili, Principles, Rules and Benefits", Tehran: The Institute of Farhang o Andishe Eslami’s Publication.
    5. Bahjat Por, Abdol karim (1394): Recognition of Tanzili of Qur’an’s Soreh. Qum: The Institute of Tamhid’s Publication.
    6. Chehri, Majid (1393): Tafsir in the order of Tanzil, Basics, Benefits, Challenges, Requirements. Hosna. Issue 23.
    7. Khamegar, Mohamad (1396): A Glance at the Way the Sūras of the Holy Qur’ān were Revealed. Qur’anic Reasearches. Issue 85. Doi: 22081/jqr.2017.46911.1458
    8. Seyed Morteza, Ali ibn Hosien (1377): Tanzih Alanbya. Qum: Dar Asharif Arazi Publication.
    9. Majlesi, Mohamad Bagher (1403): Behar Alanvar, 2th ed. Beirut: Dar Ehya Atorath Alarabi Publication.
    10. Ravandi, Said ibn Hebatola (1406): Menhaj Albraa. Qum: Marashi Lib Publication.
    11. Rajabi & others, Mahmod (1379): Methodology of Quran Interpretation. Tehran: Alhadi Publication.
    12. Rezaee Esfehani, Mohamd Ali (1393): Textbook of Quranic Interpretation Methods, 2th ed. Qum: Jameato Almostafa Publication.
    13. Sadr, Seyed Mosa (1389): Assessment of the Proofs Presented by the Proponents and Opponents of Interpretation Based on the Revelation Order. Qur’anic Reasearches. Issue 62.
    14. Tabatabae, Seyed Mohamad Hosein (1417): Almizan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an. 5th ed. Qum: Jame Modaresin Publication.
    15. Tabarsi, Fazl Ibn Hasan (1372): Majma al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an. 3th ed. Tehran: Naser Khosro Publication.
    16. Attar Abkenari, Mostafa (1398): Study of the Function of Taking into Account Tanzil (Revelation) in the Maarej Al-Tafakor VA Daghyegh Al-Tadabor. THE QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF Theological – Doctrinal Research. Issue 36.
    17. Fakhr Addin Razi, Mohamad Ibn Omar (1420): Mafatih al-Gheyb. 3th ed. Beirut: Dar Ehya Atorath Alarabi Publication.
    18. Marefat, Mohamad Hadi (1380): Tafsir Va Mofaseran. Qum: The Institute of Tamhid’s Publication.
    19. Marefat, Mohamad Hadi (1425): Al-Tamhid fi Olom al- Qur’an. 4th ed. Qum: Islamic Publishing Institute.
    20. Mofid, Mohamad Ibn Noman (1413): Al-Fosol al-Mokhtara. Qum: Sheikh Mofid Millennium World Congress Publication.
    21. Al-Meidani, Abdo al-Arahman Hasan (1420): Maarej Al-Tafakor VA Daghyegh Al-Tadabor. 1th ed. Damascus:Dar al-Ghalam Publication.
    22. Al-Meidani, Abdo al-Arahman Hasan (1430): Ghavaed al-Tadabor al-Amsal, 4th ed, Damascus: Dar al-Ghalam Publication.

  • Receive Date 29 May 2021
  • Revise Date 25 June 2023
  • Accept Date 27 June 2023
  • Publish Date 22 June 2023